Welfare proposals in Milburn review explained

12 mins read

Wednesday 18 November 2026

Yesterday, the Milburn Review into Young People and Work published its final report.

The report recommends replacing benefits that young disabled people currently get with an entirely new system of payments. Young disabled people under 25 would no longer receive Personal Independence Payment (PIP) or Universal Credit. Four new benefits will form a new benefits system.

In our article below, our benefits experts explain these proposals in detail.

From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation also sets out proposals to expand work opportunities and enhance practical support for young people. Milburn’s vision of expanded opportunities and support to help young people move into work, training or education is welcome. But we are deeply concerned that the proposed benefits changes will leave many disabled young people and their families much worse off.

In this article

Youth Opportunity Service

Milburn wants each area in England to have a new local Youth Opportunity Service. This service will bring together employment, careers, health and practical support for each young person. Each young person will have a named adviser and a personal plan.

Four new benefits replace Universal Credit & PIP

Milburn recommends that young people aged under 25 should no longer be able to claim either Personal Independence Payment (PIP) or Universal Credit.

Instead, it proposes an entirely new system of benefit payments for disabled young people.

This will be made up of four new benefits.

The Youth Allowance

This is a basic means-tested payment for all young people whether disabled or not. It would be paid at the same rate as the standard allowance for young people within Universal Credit (£338.58 pcm). Young people living independently would receive a higher rate.

The Youth Allowance will have no equivalent to the Universal Credit health element. Its introduction would mean the end of the Work Capability Assessment. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) uses this medical assessment to decide whether someone has a limited capability for work.

Everyone who receives the new Youth Allowance and who is working will be allowed a work allowance. This means an initial amount of earnings that will be disregarded and not deducted from their benefit.

A local Health and Disability Fund

Where a young person has financial needs that are “immediate, one-off or may change as treatment or support takes effect”, they will be able to apply for financial assistance to a local Fund run by their Youth Opportunity Service.

For example, they may need a piece of equipment or travel costs to attend training.

An Additional Costs Allowance

This new benefit will replace PIP for under 25s.

Like PIP, this will not be means-tested. Young people can receive it regardless of whether they are in or out of work.

Eligibility to PIP is based on assessing a claimant’s function across a range of activities. In contrast, entitlement to this new benefit would be linked to establishing “demonstrable extra costs for functional needs that are long-term and enduring”.  This might mean showing that a young person has costs for things like assistance, mobility, specialist transport, or other practical help required for daily living and independence.

A separate Timms review later this month is likely to announce changes to PIP for over 25s. It’s not clear how closely the Additional Costs Allowance will mirror these changes.

The Milburn Report doesn’t say how much young people on the Additional Costs Allowance are likely to receive. But it acknowledges that “for many, the settlement that replaces PIP would pay less cash, at least to begin with”.

A new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance

This is a new higher-rate disability benefit for the most severely disabled young people for whom work is not seen as a realistic possibility.

Milburn recommends that young people who qualify should receive higher payments than under the current benefits system. Rather than a lengthy assessment process, entitlement decisions will be based on clinical, educational and other evidence already available.

However, it also appears that much lower numbers of disabled young people will be eligible for this benefit than currently get the Universal Credit health element.

Who is eligible for Severe and Complex Needs Insurance?

Unfortunately, the report does not make this clear.

Milburn says those who qualify might include young people with severe or profound and multiple learning disabilities or those whose disability means they require continuous, 24-hour care and support.

He also says that he would like to see a very high bar for qualification. This would mean “as few people as possible end up on this route”.

The qualifying tests are not likely to be set out in detail until the government responds to Milburn’s recommendations and publishes a White Paper in the new year.  

What does Milburn say about Disability Living Allowance?

Milburn recommends that Disability Living Allowance (DLA) continues until age 18 rather than 16.

During these additional two years on DLA, 16-and-17 year olds will engage with their local Youth Opportunity Service to build their work and life skills ahead of transitioning to the new adult system.

Other changes to DLA rules were outside the scope of Milburn’s Review. He does, however, recommend that the government consider whether there is a need for reform of DLA.

How will the changes impact carer’s benefits?

Where a young person gets the daily living component of PIP, it’s possible for someone like their parent to claim benefits as their carer. This includes the carer element of Universal Credit and Carer’s Allowance.

Unfortunately, Milburn doesn’t address the issue of how PIP’s replacement will affect carers. Presumably, some people looking after a disabled young person on the new Additional Costs Allowance will continue to qualify for benefits as a carer. But this is simply not discussed in the report.

The report also fails to mention how PIPs replacement will impact on passporting to other financial support. This includes the Motability Scheme, Council Tax discounts or a parent’s entitlement to a disabled child addition for an 18 or 19 year old within their own Universal Credit award.

The government will need to answer these questions if they accept Milburn’s proposals.

When would these changes happen?

Milburn believes that the necessary employment opportunities and support services for young people should be in place before any changes to benefits system. His report suggests that this may not happen until 2029.

The exact date the new benefits are introduced in your area may vary. The report talks of a roll-out to different areas.

Are existing claimants protected?

Milburn recommendeds that these benefits changes apply to all under 25s, including existing claimants. However, the government will decide whether they agree or want to limit the changes to new claimants only. 

Milburn recommends that once an area has sufficiently established their Youth Opportunity Service and the necessary employment and health supports are in place, all new claims for benefits by young people in that area will be to Youth Allowance, Additional Costs Allowance and the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance.

Milburn proposes that existing claimants already on Universal Credit or PIP be assessed for the new benefits at their first scheduled reassessment following a six-month preparation period with the newly established Youth Opportunity Service in their area.

Are disabled young people not NEET protected?

1 in 4 under 25s getting the Universal Credit health element are not NEET, but in education, training or part-time employment. Many young people on PIP will also not be NEET.

Our expectation is that the introduction of this new benefits system will impact all under 25s. However, the report suggests that there will be some protection for young people claiming existing benefits who are already in work or training.

It says that for those “with established and ongoing extra costs who already combine PIP with education or work, transition should preserve the enabling financial support on which their participation depends”.  More detail is needed as to whether this will only apply to PIP or to the Universal Credit health element as well.

Are new benefits conditional on taking up work and training?

Milburn expects that most young disabled people will be required to take steps to help them participate in employment, training and education to the best of their abilities.

Everyone who receives the Youth Allowance will need to engage with their Youth Opportunity Service. They should be working towards either earning a wage or moving into education or training. What steps you are expected to take is likely to vary from individual to individual.

Where someone is deemed to have failed to engage without good reason, they could face sanctions. This might include the loss of their benefit. Milburn hopes that sanctions will be a rare, last resort, only used after multiple attempts to reengage that young person.  

Those in receipt of Additional Costs Allowance only would also be expected to engage with their Youth Opportunity Service. Those who qualify for the new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance will have some limited on-going contact with their Youth Opportunity Service. But they will not be obliged to engage in any work, training or education.

What losses could young people face?

A minority of disabled young people who qualify for the new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance will receive higher payments than under the current system. However, it seems likely that most disabled young people will not be entitled to this new higher rate benefit.

Instead, it seems that many disabled young people on benefits will be worse off. The loss of a Universal Credit health element comes alongside the riskthey qualify for less help under the new Additional Costs Allowance than they get via PIP.

This could lead to very substantial cuts in the benefits paid to young people. The loss of a Universal Credit health element alone would be £430 pcm for some young people. Losses will be much higher if that young person also does not qualify for the new Additional Costs Allowance.

How does the report justify these cuts?

Milburn accepts that many disabled young people will receive less benefits in the short term. But he envisages that in the longer term, some of these young people should be able to move into work. In turn, their income increases through earnings.

For example, under the Job Guarantee scheme, all disabled young people who have not moved into employment or education after 12 months are supposed to have the offer of a government-subsidised paid job for six months.

However, this assumes that the wider reforms Milburn envisages in education, training and support will result in enough work placements able to meet the additional needs of disabled young people. It also assumes that those who don’t qualify for the new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance will realistically have the capacity to engage with services and move into employment, despite their significant disabilities.

If insufficient suitable work placements are created, or the support offered isn’t personalised enough, or the bar to qualifying for the new benefits is set too high, the result is likely to be long-term severe hardship for many disabled young people and their families.

What is Contact doing about the benefit proposals?

For now, yesterday’s announcements are just proposals. However, we understand that they are likely to be extremely worrying for many families.

The government is expected to respond to Milburn’s recommendations in the New Year. If accepted, there will need to be legislation passed. Contact has already been campaigning against these benefit proposals for some time. We will continue to do so as the government considers its response to the Milburn Report.

Help us protect disabled young people’s financial support

We know these recommendations will be worrying for many families. Contact is challenging proposals that could leave disabled young people worse off, and you can help.

Email your MP and ask them to press ministers to protect financial support as they develop their response to Milburn. We’ve prepared an email which you can personalise.

If you have contacted your MP before, this is an important moment to follow up: the review has now been published, and the government is deciding what to do next.

Background to the Milburn review

The government asked Alan Milburn, an ex- Labour Minister, to carry out a wide-ranging review into the high numbers of young people who are Not in Employment, Education or Training (NEET).

After more than a year of evidence gathering, he has published his final report. It calls for huge changes. Not only to the help available to get young people into employment, but also to the benefits disabled young people can claim.

The review applies to young people in England only. However, the other nations will need to consider to what extent they will need to replicate any changes.

What are the report’s other recommendations?

The Milburn Report is hugely ambitious. It recommends major changes to the youth labour market, education, and health services for young people.

Milburn also envisages two new legal guarantees. An Opportunity Guarantee  would give each young person a guaranteed route into education, training or work. A Support Guarantee would provide the health, employment and practical help a young person needs to take up those opportunities.

Sign up to our newsletters